Saturday, April 6, 2013

A Reflection of My Formal Education: Ahistoricity... We Are All Treaty People!


Today I attended the last class of my undergraduate education, Indigenous Feminisms. This week’s readings and class discussion were dedicated to the politics of solidarity and alliances. My group was assigned a slide to present that read “We Are All Treaty People”. We talked about the failure of the government to recognize or respect treaties (ie. violation of treaty rights by Bill C-45) as a failure to uphold our end of the agreement. We discussed possible reasons for the widespread tolerance of violations of treaty agreements. We decided that tolerance to these violations could be explained by feelings of entitlement that settlers have to land and governance structures due to the normalization of, and desire to historicize, colonialism and settlement. We then talked about how to responsibly negotiate participation and solidarity as allies. Naturally, this had me consider my complicity in colonialism as a settler and my responsibility and place as an Indigenous ally.

 While negotiating my responsibility in processes of colonialism and my place as an ally in Indigenous struggles has always been complicated, I have to admit that I have not always considered my complicity in processes of colonialism of my place as an ally to Indigenous struggles. For the past week, the final week of my undergrad, I have been reflecting upon the social and educational experiences that I have had over the past five years at Queen’s, as well as the educational experiences I had before I arrived here. This week’s material has really prompted me to consider how I’ve come to recognize and understand the privilege that I gain and how I benefit from colonial relations. The memories have been bittersweet…

The first time I remember learning about colonialism and settlement of indigenous populations and lands in Canada was in grade nine history. The colonization of Indigenous peoples was taught as a single unit and we discussed it as if it was a minor, secondary event. My first memorable “educational” experience of colonialism and settlement of Indigenous populations by European settlers left me with an understanding that;

-       the brave settlers arrived in North America
-       they made contact with Indigenous peoples
-       the settlers and indigenous populations traded ideas and goods  
-       the settlers and indigenous populations made alliances
-        the settlers unwittingly killed some indigenous peoples through disease…oh, and also... they killed and enslaved some Indigenous peoples purposely
-       it was amazing that the settlers made it through the winter!
-       The settlers and Indigenous peoples signed a treaty and colonialism ended!

My first real experience with responsible education of issues of settlement and colonization was in second year. Interestingly enough, in Racism, Colonialism and Resistance taught by Professor Scott Morgensen. This was the first time that I was introduced to the reality that although formal colonization is over that very real and pervasive systems and processes of colonization still remain deeply embedded in Canadian society, that the ongoing occupation of Indigenous peoples' territories is certainly a contemporary reality... AND that *I* was complicit in in these realities. I’m ashamed to admit that I was initially hostile to the reality that I was a part and benefactor of colonial processes. However, I quickly came to see the truth in this reality, but I still didn’t know how to work towards a solution to mollify unequal colonial relations and help to create equitable social structures and processes beyond simply recognizing my privilege.

Prof. Morgensen’s class was also the first time I was introduced to the concept of allyship. One of the most important thing I learned in this class about allyship is the necessity of recognizing my position and privilege, educating myself on Indigenous issues, and engaging myself in indigenous conversations and activism while recognizing my appropriate limits as a non-Indigenous settler woman. In Unsettling Queer Politics: What Can Non-Natives Learn from Two-Spirit Organizing, Morgensen writes about non-Native accountability and approach to decolonizing conversations about Two-Spirit peoples in a way that echoes what his course first taught me about allyship. He concludes the article by recognizing the need to respectfully and responsibly join Indigenous organizing and conversations as an outsider with the responsibility to participate in a self critical and self reflexive way. He writes,

Breaking from the idea that the world already positioned me in a way that is useful to Native organizing, I became repositioned within Native conversations on gender, sexuality, and decolonization that inform the claims I make to return to conversation… in a decolonial reading, these conversations are places where non-Natives are invited, not where they already live or can arrive unannounced (149).

Here, Morgensen stresses the importance of ally participation through including yourself quietly, humbly and accountable in Indigenous conversations.

I am embarrassed and regretful that my early education did not expose me to, and I did not seek information regarding, the ongoing reality of settler colonialism, indigenous struggles and allyship. I do not think that my early educational experience regarding settler colonialism is isolated or even uncommon. To be sure, I believe that the quiet systems and processes of colonization are able to function precisely because of the ahistorical normalization and naturalization of settler colonialism.

The covert nature of the informal processes of colonization allow it’s benefactors and participants believe that we live in a post-colonial society and consider themselves free of responsibility in ongoing colonial processes and structures. With graduation around the corner I feel an unfortunate sense of luckiness and privilege to have spent five years studying a program that forced and allowed me to critically reflect upon my the implications of my position as a white woman living on stolen land.

Here is a good link to Ally Bill of Responsibilities: