Saturday, April 6, 2013

A Reflection of My Formal Education: Ahistoricity... We Are All Treaty People!


Today I attended the last class of my undergraduate education, Indigenous Feminisms. This week’s readings and class discussion were dedicated to the politics of solidarity and alliances. My group was assigned a slide to present that read “We Are All Treaty People”. We talked about the failure of the government to recognize or respect treaties (ie. violation of treaty rights by Bill C-45) as a failure to uphold our end of the agreement. We discussed possible reasons for the widespread tolerance of violations of treaty agreements. We decided that tolerance to these violations could be explained by feelings of entitlement that settlers have to land and governance structures due to the normalization of, and desire to historicize, colonialism and settlement. We then talked about how to responsibly negotiate participation and solidarity as allies. Naturally, this had me consider my complicity in colonialism as a settler and my responsibility and place as an Indigenous ally.

 While negotiating my responsibility in processes of colonialism and my place as an ally in Indigenous struggles has always been complicated, I have to admit that I have not always considered my complicity in processes of colonialism of my place as an ally to Indigenous struggles. For the past week, the final week of my undergrad, I have been reflecting upon the social and educational experiences that I have had over the past five years at Queen’s, as well as the educational experiences I had before I arrived here. This week’s material has really prompted me to consider how I’ve come to recognize and understand the privilege that I gain and how I benefit from colonial relations. The memories have been bittersweet…

The first time I remember learning about colonialism and settlement of indigenous populations and lands in Canada was in grade nine history. The colonization of Indigenous peoples was taught as a single unit and we discussed it as if it was a minor, secondary event. My first memorable “educational” experience of colonialism and settlement of Indigenous populations by European settlers left me with an understanding that;

-       the brave settlers arrived in North America
-       they made contact with Indigenous peoples
-       the settlers and indigenous populations traded ideas and goods  
-       the settlers and indigenous populations made alliances
-        the settlers unwittingly killed some indigenous peoples through disease…oh, and also... they killed and enslaved some Indigenous peoples purposely
-       it was amazing that the settlers made it through the winter!
-       The settlers and Indigenous peoples signed a treaty and colonialism ended!

My first real experience with responsible education of issues of settlement and colonization was in second year. Interestingly enough, in Racism, Colonialism and Resistance taught by Professor Scott Morgensen. This was the first time that I was introduced to the reality that although formal colonization is over that very real and pervasive systems and processes of colonization still remain deeply embedded in Canadian society, that the ongoing occupation of Indigenous peoples' territories is certainly a contemporary reality... AND that *I* was complicit in in these realities. I’m ashamed to admit that I was initially hostile to the reality that I was a part and benefactor of colonial processes. However, I quickly came to see the truth in this reality, but I still didn’t know how to work towards a solution to mollify unequal colonial relations and help to create equitable social structures and processes beyond simply recognizing my privilege.

Prof. Morgensen’s class was also the first time I was introduced to the concept of allyship. One of the most important thing I learned in this class about allyship is the necessity of recognizing my position and privilege, educating myself on Indigenous issues, and engaging myself in indigenous conversations and activism while recognizing my appropriate limits as a non-Indigenous settler woman. In Unsettling Queer Politics: What Can Non-Natives Learn from Two-Spirit Organizing, Morgensen writes about non-Native accountability and approach to decolonizing conversations about Two-Spirit peoples in a way that echoes what his course first taught me about allyship. He concludes the article by recognizing the need to respectfully and responsibly join Indigenous organizing and conversations as an outsider with the responsibility to participate in a self critical and self reflexive way. He writes,

Breaking from the idea that the world already positioned me in a way that is useful to Native organizing, I became repositioned within Native conversations on gender, sexuality, and decolonization that inform the claims I make to return to conversation… in a decolonial reading, these conversations are places where non-Natives are invited, not where they already live or can arrive unannounced (149).

Here, Morgensen stresses the importance of ally participation through including yourself quietly, humbly and accountable in Indigenous conversations.

I am embarrassed and regretful that my early education did not expose me to, and I did not seek information regarding, the ongoing reality of settler colonialism, indigenous struggles and allyship. I do not think that my early educational experience regarding settler colonialism is isolated or even uncommon. To be sure, I believe that the quiet systems and processes of colonization are able to function precisely because of the ahistorical normalization and naturalization of settler colonialism.

The covert nature of the informal processes of colonization allow it’s benefactors and participants believe that we live in a post-colonial society and consider themselves free of responsibility in ongoing colonial processes and structures. With graduation around the corner I feel an unfortunate sense of luckiness and privilege to have spent five years studying a program that forced and allowed me to critically reflect upon my the implications of my position as a white woman living on stolen land.

Here is a good link to Ally Bill of Responsibilities:


Saturday, March 30, 2013

Indigenous Solidarity


This week in class one class presenter encouraged the class to recognize their privilege and talk about it, despite it being uncomfortable. They encouraged us to recognize when we’ve been compliant to our privilege, which is even more uncomfortable. It’s something I’ve struggled with on a personal level, and I think the great thing about blogs is that it gives people a space to come to terms with more personal, challenging, and awkward material.  

So let’s get personal.  

My paternal grandparents, in my eyes, are truly exceptional people. My grandfather was a Reverend, father, husband, counsellor, carpenter, songwriter, cheese-whiz lover, and astrologist. My grandmother was a wife, mother, Girl Guide leader, birdwatcher, tetris-lover, and feminist. They belonged to the NDP party, played scrabble, and spent all of their money on books and charitable donations.   

And in the 1950s they ran Old Sun Residential School in Gleichen Alberta.  My grandfather was a Residential School Principal. Now isn’t that uncomfortable to mention in a class about Indigenous Feminist Resistance?    

Old Sun Residential School


The Crocker family at Old Sun, from the Glenbow Museum Archives

Both of my grandparents died when I was young, and although I knew my Granny pretty well, I knew my Grandpa more so through the stories my Dad and Aunts and Uncle have told me. The way I understand it is that things didn’t go so well in Gleichen, Aberta. There were certain rules and regulations my grandparents refused to follow, such as physical punishment and not allowing the children to speak their Native language. I don’t know much about their time at Old Sun, and I wish I could go back in a time machine sixty years and watch their day-to-day lives, or read a diary about it all. All I know is that authorities didn’t approve of their breaking the rules and they threatened to fire my Grandpa, and so instead my grandparents decided to quit and move back to Ontario.   

Shortly after this, they purchased a cottage about 1km away from the Chippewas of Nawash Reserve near Wiarton, and from there became involved in Native rights. I remember my grandmother taking us to pow-wows and talking openly about Native rights issues. She learned to speak Ojibwa and Blackfoot languages. To me, my grandmother is a great example of solidarity, and she’s a role model to me.  

This all said, I find my family history very challenging, and I am both proud and ashamed of it. On one hand, my deep connections with the Crockers are central to who I am. On the other hand, I’ve struggled knowing that my grandparents were part of a system that existed to actively assimilate a huge group of people and conduct cultural genocide. Yes, they decided to leave this system, but I can’t help but wonder why they went to Gleichen in the first place and if they knew exactly what they were getting into. Even more so, I wonder why my grandmother, a published author on top of everything else, didn’t openly write about their unique experiences in Gleichen, which could have provided insight into Canada’s colonial history. I struggle knowing that my grandparents were proud members of the Church institution that was active in the colonization of indigenous peoples. Even today, the Anglican Church of Canada’s webpage on Old Sun does not recognize the assimilationist objectives of the school or colonial history of the church.   

My grandparents, and me by extension, hold so much privilege not just because we’re white settler Canadians, but because being white settler Canadians allow us to pick and choose when to act in solidarity and when to be compliant. We can own land off reserve but attend a pow-wow. We can hold a sign protesting for Native rights but still belong to an institution that tried to take away those very rights. In class I criticize stereotypes of Native peoples, but when an acquaintance makes a rude comment about “drunk Indians,” I shrug it off.   

I’m beginning to dive into material on “how to be an ally,” and I think lists like this one are great, because they encourage dialogue.  But we must be mindful that dialogue is a balance. It isn’t just telling your own stories, but listening and being reflective as well. This blog writer criticizes some white allies as being unable to “take a seat and listen when needed.”       
I am guilty of claiming to be a feminist and an ally of Indigenous movements, meanwhile being compliant to mainstream colonial society. Although this is blog has shared a personal example, I think a lot of my friends could think of how they have failed their indigenous peers in one way or another. I think that people shrug off their compliancy too easily, thinking of privilege as too engrained to really do anything about it. But I think talking about the mistakes we make and the challenges we have is a first step in actively resisting, and an important dialogue to have throughout the process, and I hope that my peers also feel inspired by this class to talk about their mistakes and challenges.  

_________________________________________________________________________________

If you want to learn more about the types of abuses that happened at residential schools: http://www.legacyofhope.ca/about-residential-schools/conditions-mistreatment  

Or about truth & reconciliation: http://www.trc.ca/websites/trcinstitution/index.php?p=3

Thursday, March 21, 2013

“… the concept of betraying one’s race through sex and sexual politics is as common as corn”



I take a running jump from the imaginary precipice and BAM, I collapse to my knees on the laminate flooring all while yelling “GERONIMOOOOO” at the top of my lungs. I raise my head and see my fellow group members beaming and applauding. From down the hall I can hear snippets of laughter, definitely my roommate and her boyfriend making fun at the expense of my poor knees (SHUT UP! The right one has had reconstructive surgery).
Why did I throw myself so unceremoniously in the tiny confines of my living room, in front of a small audience no less? Well, the neighbours in the apartment below mine are CONSTANTLY playing loud music and electric guitar. I figure if I throw all my weight to the floor once in a while, it should remind them that I am not nearly as annoying as them and they should pipe down more often. As effective as this strategy sounds, in actuality I did it because I was performing the opening scene from Monique Mojica’s play Princess Pocahontas and the Blue Spots. My fellow bloggers and I spent the better part of two hours reading this play aloud and taking turns performing scenes, or as Mojica dubs them, “Transformations.” In the ten “Transformations,” the play weaves the journeys taken by Contemporary Woman #1 and Contemporary Woman #2 with the stories and histories surrounding four prominent indigenous women or groups of women in the early onset of colonialism in the New World: La Malinche, partner to Hernan Cortez (the Spaniard who invaded Mexico), the Woman of the Puna/Deity/Virgin of colonial Peru, the First Nations wives of the fur traders in  Canada and Pocahontas/Matoaka/Lady Rebecca and the settlers at Jamestown Virginia.

In the first transformation, I was acting the role of Princess Buttered-on-Both-Sides, a contestant of the fictitious and satirical “500 Years of the Miss North American Beauty Pagent,” and illustrating the character’s undying love for John Whiteman (more commonly known as Smith) by throwing myself into Niagara Falls, which, in this case is my living room floor.
With characters like the “Blue Spots” and “Princess Buttered-on-Both-Sides” saying lines such as: “you’re the cheese in my fondue” and “be my muffin, I’ll be your marmalade”, it seems like a random assortment of weird characters and their phrases, instead, these coalesce to evince the brilliance and wit of Mojica. In the opening Transformation, Princess Buttered-on-Both-Sides tells her audience, “I shall dance for you in savage splendour, the Dance of the sacrificial Corn Maiden”, demonstrating the playwright’s innate ability to frame the ahistorical and normative understandings of indigenous women as both ridiculous and with humorous exaggeration; an effective tactic in compelling the audience to consider the alternative, or to simply question the history and stereotypes spoon-fed through Disney, pop culture and reinforced through biased and complacent education systems.
As Shari Hundorf argues in her reflection of Mojica as a playwright- the idea that indigenous women were in love with white men and played a role in facilitating their settlement of the New World, the onus of settler guilt is reduced, if not removed. The indigenous man is still regarded as a fierce warrior, defending his nation and fighting the threat to the way of life he knows and loves, while his female counterpart must carry the blame and shame for her role in destroying it. Further, because indigenous women are the exotic “other” to the white man but also possess the ability to reproduce future generations of non-settlers, or children of mixed blood, they are seen as threats and deserving of objectification, be it sexual or violent to settler men- these same men who benefited from the brokerage of peace arranged by the indigenous woman.
This interpretation is dangerous on many levels and the prevalence of this perspective is reflected by the current status and treatment of Aboriginal women in North America, one of the worst demographics in nearly every category: suicide rates, health, incarceration, physical and sexual abuse, etc. While many are aware that the situation for our First Nations women is dire, it is through song, dance, dialogue and monologue that Mojita’s characters impose a historical lens that forces the audience to re-examine our popular notions of who indigenous women are, and where this popularization came from.
 

Indigenous women (and men) have a history where colonialism tried to destroy them, and this trend remained and continues to be perpetrated in settler society. As Jessica Danforth points out, “this can be uncomfortable to the settler.” She’s right. As a feminist, a settler  and a student I am willing and wanting  to learn about the ‘legacy’ that is colonialism, but having to come to terms with the fact that my settler and white privilege came to be because it was ripped away from someone who was indigenous – is  undoubtedly uncomfortable. Reading and acting out Mojica’s Princess Pocahontas and the Blue Spots provided this medium for which I felt more comfortable challenging my discomfort as a settler. Mojica’s sarcasm and wit, interlaced with powerful stories of the indigenous women dealing with the front lines of colonialism in the contact period prompted me to revaluate and reflect on all the ahistorical and mainstream media infused perspectives on indigenous women, but it also allowed me to laugh.


Friday, March 15, 2013

Performance Art and Indigeneity in Canada


This week, I was really pleased to read Julie Nagan’s “(Re)mapping the Colonized Body: The Creative Interventions of Rebecca Belmore in the Cityscape”. I consider myself a fan of performance art and its provocative power. I recently watched Marina Abramovic’s film “The Artist is Present”, which reinforced my appreciation for performance art as a vehicle for critical thought and self-reflection. A performance artist can challenge an audience and themselves to look at things differently, to feel uncomfortable and to question their own thoughts, ideas and emotions. Indigenous artists such as Ken Monkman (mentioned in our first group blog post) and Rebecca Belmore have the power to challenge ideas about colonization, settler identity and what it means to be indigenous.

Rebecca Belmore focuses her performances on the colonization of the gendered indigenous body, and the absence of indigenous peoples from the Canadian map. Of course, to truly understand the magnitude of importance in Belmore’s work, we need to acknowledge the blatant symbolism of land colonization for the domination of indigenous bodies. We’ve all heard the stories about settlers arriving on “Canadian soil”, colonizing it, and shaping it into what we now call “our home and native land”. Often forgotten however, is the fact that these settlers colonized more than the land; they colonized indigenous bodies. They exercised the same sense of entitlement, dominance and disregard that they showed the land toward people’s most personal possession: their bodies. Furthermore, Belmore addresses the blatant negligence to acknowledge indigenous bodies and nations on the Canadian map. Disregard for indigenous bodies as members of “Canadian” land provokes questions about value placement, disruption of agency and the settler sense of entitlement.

One of Belmore’s performance pieces draws attention to the high volume of missing and murdered Aboriginal women from Vancouver’s downtown East side. The nature of her performance piece is evocative and aims to make the viewer feel uncomfortable as she pushes her own boundaries and the boundaries of others by expressing emotional and physical pain.



As I read about the specifics of Belmore’s performance, I wondered how I might react to each one. I identify as a white, heterosexual, settler female. Some aspects of my identity intersect with Belmore and the women whose struggles she addresses in her performance and other aspects could never possibly intersect.  Thus, my interpretation would differ greatly from that of others. How would I feel while she shouts out the names of Aboriginal female victims? Would I feel sadness? Empathy? Female unity? Guilt? How would I feel when she nails her dress to a pole and repeatedly rips herself away from it? How would an indigenous woman residing in Vancouver’s East side feel? How would my Dad or my brother feel?

Rebecca Belmore and others like her are doing important work. She is peeling away the layers of settler identity, indigenous identity and colonization in Canada. She is forcing people to look at something that hurts their eyes, to hear the shrill cry of years of injustice and to acknowledge something that it so easy for many to ignore. She is creating discomfort, forcing acknowledgement, and igniting emotions that will engrain themselves deeply into the hearts and minds of her viewers.

The "Imaginary Indian"


I tend to imagine things- a lot. I find myself reconstructing my life in my head, rearranging the things that make up who I am, what I do, where I live.

I imagine myself because there, I am the master of my own universe- and it feels damn good.

When things are imagined we can wish them away, make them fit into our narrow conceptions of reality, recreate them in relation to our own senses of self.

These are the things I have been thinking about this week while engaging with the course readings surrounding “the imaginary Indian”. Since the European ‘master narrative’ has come onto the scene, Indigenous people have been recreated as fictitious characters which fit into a fictions history.

I find it sort of funny; I live with two history majors who won’t even watch the news because, to them, it hasn’t really happened yet. Therefore it isn’t history, it isn’t in the past and able to observe, debate, quantify.
 
This is the aspect which struck me the most, when I was reading Marcia Crosby’s article “Constructing the Imaginary Indian”. For a long time, due to the colonial nature of history, we ‘studied’ and observed Indigenous people as though they no longer existed. They are history because they have no future, due to discourses of binary polarization where the future is modern, progressive, civilized and this is an incompatible reality from living an ‘Indigenous life’. People were seen as indigenous subjects, who were to be saved through colonization and civilization.

But Indigenous people exist. One of my best friends identifies as Cree, and she goes to pow-wows, goes to school, paints in a style which reminds her of her heritage, and has a status card. She lives a life in the modern world, as a modern person; not an archaic subject.

(Let me bring in Foucault for a second...)

Foucault talks about biopolitics. It’s not that sensitive topics like sex cannot be discussed at all, but only certain people, in certain contexts have the power to do so. It has been demonstrated that the colonial narrative is acted on Indigenous people, in such a way, that they became unable to legitimately discuss themselves as people. They become objects of the colonial gaze and things frozen in a specific time and place.

Crosby discusses the feeling of not being able to embrace the notion of the ‘authentic’ Indian which she saw reproduced by the Western science of anthropology. As she was sitting in class being impressed by this huge amount of knowledge her professor had on Indigenous subject matter, he still looked to her for verification.
She found herself embarrassed by her lack of knowledge but, for the first time, presented with a positive stereotype of what a `real’ Indian should be like. Despite all his knowledge, the professor was still unknowingly constructing Crosby, in a way which she did not self-identify nor did she feel like she had ownership over.

I feel as though as racially, socially, economically privileged people; we are constantly guilty of this; where we construct the identities of those who do not have as much power.

This can be due to the education system, an unfortunate effect of having two histories running parallel to one another, where neither of them have been intertwined. Crosby speaks to the paradox where people are criticized for only teaching/speaking about Eurocentric history; but at the same time should not speak to cultures and histories where they have to make assumptions. The solution to this is bringing in members of these communities in order to discuss their work, first hand, but this is somewhat unrealistic in certain contexts.

The Crosby text discusses counter narratives which need to take into account the juxtaposition of this imaginedness, while attempting to reclaim narratives. George Bowering’s text Burning Water is a historical parody of George Vancouver’s ‘discovery’ of the northwest coast. He presents the subject matter as drunken, dirty, promiscuous Indian women. For those who know that this description is a parody, they understand that this is a critique of the ‘master narrative’ and does not describe reality. In reality, Crosby notes that Bowering does not consider that there is very little primary information about Indigenous people in the education system. So little, in fact, that readers would have a hard time determining that this text is parody and perhaps could interpret these descriptions as reality.

A similar situation occurred at the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) in the late 1990’s when they put on the show “Into the Heart of Africa”. For the first time African artifacts were put on display for the public, but there was intense backlash from the Afro-Canadian community. Most of the artifacts had been collected during colonial times, or by missionaries and were accompanied by captions similar to what Bowering did in his text. Pictures of tribal warriors were accompanied by phrases like “uncivilized” or “barbaric culture”, all in quotation marks. These quotation marks were supposed to indicate to the observer that these assumptions were wrong, and that it was not the opinion of the exhibit, but rather the opinion of a group of people involved in this history, who ‘collected’ this history. The Afro-Canadian community had grievances that an uneducated audience would not understand that these phrases were supposed to be satirical, and would take them at face value.

This exhibit therefore was geared to a certain educated audience, making this exhibit inaccessible for those who were not privy to information on colonialism or missionaries; therefore cutting off all opportunity for a wider audience to enjoy it. Yes, these artifacts had to be observed in a certain historical context, however I question the validity of placing them in the colonial context, disregarding whether or not these artefacts were collected during this time.

More of a gap must be bridged between mainstream Eurocentric education, and those who wish to offer a counter-narrative. I believe that it will be necessary to completely refigure what education means, how it is taught and how information is collected- in order to properly close this gap.

Last year in DEVS 300, one of our TAs Shauna Shiels, got up to speak about her research concerning reclaiming Indigenous methodologies. How objects and artifacts, such as beadwork and clothing that typically would be put in a museum because they are things to be observed. In reality these ‘artifacts’ actually tell stories and can be critical and self-reflexive. Objects that the West defined as ‘pretty things’, actually have deep cultural and historical meaning and the mediums in which they are made are significant too; understanding that there are different ways to disseminate knowledge and history- beyond writing it down.
That the legitimacy of information does not necessarily involve a pen, paper, and an ‘expert’ in the traditional western education sense!

But for now they do. For now, the realness of my education is defined by those things. The legitimacy of a huge part of who I am (a student) rest on how well I reconcile with this notion of education- and I can only hope that this will change.


Friday, March 1, 2013

Intervention in Canadian Law and Policy: Politicial Engagement through Social Activism

The readings assigned in this weeks class address the importance of a marriage of Aboriginal women’s theory, organizing and activism in effecting positive formal and substantive changes in law and politics for the express benefit of Aboriginal women, and Aboriginal communities at large. 

In Balancing Strategies: Aboriginal Women and Constitutional Rights in Canada, Joyce Green states that Canada’s current electoral system discourages disenfranchised and marginalized bodies and groups from pursuing democratic engagement through traditional political party involvement. But rather, she claims that activists and activist groups prefer to engage with the state through participation in social movements, claiming that theses avenues have been powerful actors in effecting formal changes in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms as well as within the Canadian Constitution. The formal changes in Canadian law and policy that have been advanced by Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s activist groups and organizations are specifically oriented towards Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s issues, for example: land rights, political autonomy and sovereignty, and respect for culture and tradition. However, Green addresses the unfortunate reality that change in law and policy rarely affects the tangible and practical realties of the everyday lived experience of disenfranchised and marginalized groups.

Green’s idea that disenfranchised and marginalized groups can, and should, participate in social activist movements and organizations in order to effectively affect changes within the Canadian political and legal systems is echoed in Smith’s article, Against the Law: Indigenous Feminism and the Nation-State. Smith argues that many non-white/ Aboriginal peoples consider their bodies and agendas to be outside or othered from mainstream feminist projects. She states that feelings of isolation and alienation from mainstream feminist projects discourage Aboriginal women from participating in, contributing to and drawing on valid and useful theoretical frameworks. As such, Smith promotes a Native feminist approach that interrogates the everyday practical and material conditions that Native women experience as subjects situated within patriarchal and colonial nation-states. Here too, as in Green’s article, Smith stresses the importance of this native feminist approach to theory and practice (activism and organizing) in decolonizing the American nation state in order to expose the fallacy of its foundation that is so effectively occluded. Again, Smith calls for an approach to Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s theory and activism that works against oppressive law and policy that promote, support and condone state-sponsored racism, domination and violence.

After reading the Green and Smith article I started to consider the ways in which colonial nation-states are able to effectively obscure the oppressive and violent histories and foundations that inform and (re)produce their current incarnations. In particular, I began thinking about injustice and discrimination that pervades Canadian laws and policies and the ways in which Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s organizations and activists work to expose inequality and negotiate positive changes that empower Aboriginal peoples, specifically Aboriginal women. 


It is clear that formal guarantees of equality in Canada do not translate to just and equal practical manifestations of the everyday lived experience of Aboriginal and diverse non-white identities.  Certainly, myriad factors and social intersections contribute to experiences of (dis)empowerment under these systems and Canadians experience the implications of Canadian law and policy in very different, and ultimately unequal, ways. However, formal guarantees of equality and justice in Canadian law and policy obscures the everyday reality that injustice and inequality pervades these systems. Because injustice and inequality are obscured by the disconnect between the formal and the substantive, those privileged by the system do not recognize the gap between the legal, policies and the theoretical on one hand and the practical, tangible and lived experience on the other. Uncritical consumption of ideology and discourse, that posits Canada’s political and legal systems as unquestioningly egalitarian, promotes dangerous ahistorical understandings of colonialism as a project of the past. These understandings minimize, undermine and create resistance by the mainstream to the organizing and activism of Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s groups in the struggle for self-determination and equality in practice and in theory. 


A relevant example of Aboriginal organizing and activism in terms of addressing injustice and inequality in the disconnect between Canadian law and policy on one hand and implementation on the other is the protest movement Idle no More. Idle no More pursues activism in response to unfair law and policy of the Canadian federal government through various political actions and interventions. Idle no more is invested in addressing violations of the Treaties that degrade their land rights, environmental protections and sovereignty, specifically violations imposed by Bill C-45. I chose to consider Idle no More because the various road and rail blockades that were implemented across Canada by the group in the late months of 2012 and early 2013 generated a lot of mainstream interest and resistance in the Queen’s community (particularly regarding the rail blockades on the route between Kingston and Toronto). 

 

I was appalled at the response to the protests that I heard from many of my peers who felt that they had been inconvenienced by the blockades. Many of the complaints I heard were in response to cancelled or delayed trains, complicating their trips back home. I remember listening to some of my peers claiming that equality in Canada had been reached, calling the protests greedy, uncalled for inconveniences. I think that these  are echoed in the comment sections of the below Globe and Mail articles (which detail the protests and provide a brief overviews of the concerns and goals of Idle no More). 

·    
-->


I remember being simultaneously angry and confused at my peer’s resistance to the Idle no More protests on grounds that equality in Canada had been achieved. While I am convinced that many of my peers didn’t really care about equality and justice for Aboriginal peoples, and were really primarily concerned with their trips home, I also think that there is a lack of (and a resistance to) understanding the reality of the implications and enforcement of Canadian law and policy on aboriginal bodies. I think that this weeks material helped me to understand that the disconnect between theory and practice in law and policy affects public perception of the ways in which marginalized groups in Canada experience inequality and discrimination. 


The disconnect between formal guarantees and practical implications necessitates Aboriginal activism and organization to engage Canadian legal and political systems in order to create an effective politics of resistance and secure equality. It is clear that the Canadian nation state has effectively obscured the violent and racist roots of its foundation that re(produce) the continuing marginalization and disenfranchisement of Aboriginal bodies. In achieving illusions of multiculturalism, acceptance and equality, through formal guarantees and provisions, the Canadian nation state and its privileged subjects are able to overlook and disregard the domination and disenfranchisement of its marginalized subjects, and justify backlash, criticism and resistance to Aboriginal activism, protest and political agendas.