Identity is complex and fluid. I, like many about-to-graduate students, face a crisis of identity on what I want to do and, more importantly, WHO I want to be.
But I am lucky.
I am a white, middle-class, educated, heterosexual, woman; and therefore I face far fewer barriers as I decide to create my own self; as opposed to others who may not be born to these ‘typical’ associations of race and class. I don’t have a set of laws or a government bureau that decides what ‘classifies’ me as a certain type of citizen; and I am not constantly facing prejudice from a greater society that seems to hold all of the cards and of all the power.
I am alluding to the debates, complexities and challenges that people of indigenous identity face as they are navigating their own senses of self, community, and belonging.
Many people self-identify as being indigenous in ways that are often in response to mainstream stereotypes or misconceptions about what it means to be indigenous. Stereotypes such as the “noble savage” place an unfair narrow conception on a large group of people. I think white people could maybe compare if media and popular narrative consistently portrayed all white men with the characteristics of a Ken doll. It is limiting to the individual associations, goals, orientations and, ultimately identities, that a large heterogeneous group of people can hold. Additionally, the Ken doll is a fantasy of capitalism and gender normativity. Similarly, the noble savage is the fantasy of colonial and settler powers.
These colonial settlers also came up with ways of identifying indigenous people. They externally identified and subjugated them. They instituted policies and regulating bodies, in order to determine ‘indigenousness’. This was at a time where there was the belief in innate characteristics of all races and ethnicities.
The colonial administration identified indigenous peoples with what they assumed was what made them all ‘Indian’, and subsequently, what had to be controlled or assimilated. This process lead to the Racialization of very distinct indigenous nations, placing them all under a homogeneous guise of Indianness, which held very narrow conceptions of identification, which we use even today.
These narrow attributes and identities were placed on indigenous people in order to make them inferior and therefore justifiably dominated and colonized. Creating binaries of civility and barbarism was a process of ‘othering’ which affirmed the perceived superiority of white culture and also reflected colonial anxieties surrounding whiteness and what it meant to be identified as white. Categorization of the indigenous identity lead to them being limited in voice, history and experience; allowing for domination of western heteronormative culture.
Indeed, it assumed heteronormativity, as this was the norm for European culture and therefore was imposed as the norm for everyone. As well, prejudice against sex was imposed on native culture, as laws controlling ‘Indian Status’ were greatly prejudiced against indigenous women. In the new colonial system. constraints to indigenous women's personal and collective identification made it impossible to navigate above and beyond their heterosexual male counterparts. This heteronormativity ignored certain Indigenous cultures that have non-Western sexual identification, such as two-spirit.
Cree artist Kent Monkman’s work addresses a variety of histories which have been dominated and repressed by colonizers. A history which white people did not write and therefore is presumed not to exist.
Due to the on-going colonial context of indigenous identities, in an attempt to reclaim pre-colonial narratives, Monkman has taken the colonial gaze and reversed it; showing these perspectives in his paintings. He makes the argument that counter-narratives such as this lend agency to indigenous history and perspectives, showing that while colonial settlers were observing indigenous peoples, they were looking back critically. This art seeks to retell history within indigenous pedagogies.
In an interview with the CBC (http://www.cbc.ca/doczone/8thfire/2011/11/kent-monkman-1.html), Monkman discusses how indigenous peoples must negotiate several identities. From his experience, this has been difficult, as identities are fluid and thus often connect to the self, the collective and external identification simultaneously.
Geography can play a big role in negotiating indigenous identity. Identity may be bound to physical tracts of land and landscapes. Perception of being a “good” or “authentic” Indian is tied to practising a certain way of life; usually connected to an assumption that indigenous people must have strong ties to the land and what it embodies. The notion that somehow being on the reserve allows for a certain identity and the reserve, a completely other; with the two sharing very little space in the middle. A Western need to “know” and compartmentalize different identities is linked to feelings of anxiety surrounding what is perceived as “White,” “Indian,” “Straight,” and other normative categories of being.
Kent retells the story of how his grandmother was accused of squatting on the land she had homesteaded on for decades, the land which she raised her children and grandchildren on. Due to the fact that she had been classified and compartmentalized as a “treaty Indian” the government required her to move, continuing a history of forced dispossession common in Canada.
Kent Monkman identifies as a two-spirited gay man Artist, but also has an alter ego named Miss Chief Eagle Testikle. He seeks to reinsert this sexual discourse, which has been lost in colonial society, into the traditional landscapes of his paintings. He explains in his interview that many white painters, including American painter George Catlin (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Catlin), wrote in their journals that they observed non-heteronormative behaviour; however chose not to paint them as it didn’t ‘fit’. Catlin wrote about encountering ‘Native American dandies’ (non-heterosexuals), however painted some of the most famous and stereotypical Indigenous American portraits. Below are two paintings by Kent which help to explain this situation.
Monkman seeks to create a counter narrative of sexuality and history which is breaking the bounds of art and performance. To view his work, please click here http://kentmonkman.com/main.php
Reclamation of identity is an ongoing process and struggle. Art,has been a way in which native identity has been reclaimed and continued to be reclaimed.
But I am lucky.
I am a white, middle-class, educated, heterosexual, woman; and therefore I face far fewer barriers as I decide to create my own self; as opposed to others who may not be born to these ‘typical’ associations of race and class. I don’t have a set of laws or a government bureau that decides what ‘classifies’ me as a certain type of citizen; and I am not constantly facing prejudice from a greater society that seems to hold all of the cards and of all the power.
I am alluding to the debates, complexities and challenges that people of indigenous identity face as they are navigating their own senses of self, community, and belonging.
Many people self-identify as being indigenous in ways that are often in response to mainstream stereotypes or misconceptions about what it means to be indigenous. Stereotypes such as the “noble savage” place an unfair narrow conception on a large group of people. I think white people could maybe compare if media and popular narrative consistently portrayed all white men with the characteristics of a Ken doll. It is limiting to the individual associations, goals, orientations and, ultimately identities, that a large heterogeneous group of people can hold. Additionally, the Ken doll is a fantasy of capitalism and gender normativity. Similarly, the noble savage is the fantasy of colonial and settler powers.
These colonial settlers also came up with ways of identifying indigenous people. They externally identified and subjugated them. They instituted policies and regulating bodies, in order to determine ‘indigenousness’. This was at a time where there was the belief in innate characteristics of all races and ethnicities.
The colonial administration identified indigenous peoples with what they assumed was what made them all ‘Indian’, and subsequently, what had to be controlled or assimilated. This process lead to the Racialization of very distinct indigenous nations, placing them all under a homogeneous guise of Indianness, which held very narrow conceptions of identification, which we use even today.
These narrow attributes and identities were placed on indigenous people in order to make them inferior and therefore justifiably dominated and colonized. Creating binaries of civility and barbarism was a process of ‘othering’ which affirmed the perceived superiority of white culture and also reflected colonial anxieties surrounding whiteness and what it meant to be identified as white. Categorization of the indigenous identity lead to them being limited in voice, history and experience; allowing for domination of western heteronormative culture.
Indeed, it assumed heteronormativity, as this was the norm for European culture and therefore was imposed as the norm for everyone. As well, prejudice against sex was imposed on native culture, as laws controlling ‘Indian Status’ were greatly prejudiced against indigenous women. In the new colonial system. constraints to indigenous women's personal and collective identification made it impossible to navigate above and beyond their heterosexual male counterparts. This heteronormativity ignored certain Indigenous cultures that have non-Western sexual identification, such as two-spirit.
Cree artist Kent Monkman’s work addresses a variety of histories which have been dominated and repressed by colonizers. A history which white people did not write and therefore is presumed not to exist.
Due to the on-going colonial context of indigenous identities, in an attempt to reclaim pre-colonial narratives, Monkman has taken the colonial gaze and reversed it; showing these perspectives in his paintings. He makes the argument that counter-narratives such as this lend agency to indigenous history and perspectives, showing that while colonial settlers were observing indigenous peoples, they were looking back critically. This art seeks to retell history within indigenous pedagogies.
| Cree Master 1 |
In an interview with the CBC (http://www.cbc.ca/doczone/8thfire/2011/11/kent-monkman-1.html), Monkman discusses how indigenous peoples must negotiate several identities. From his experience, this has been difficult, as identities are fluid and thus often connect to the self, the collective and external identification simultaneously.
Geography can play a big role in negotiating indigenous identity. Identity may be bound to physical tracts of land and landscapes. Perception of being a “good” or “authentic” Indian is tied to practising a certain way of life; usually connected to an assumption that indigenous people must have strong ties to the land and what it embodies. The notion that somehow being on the reserve allows for a certain identity and the reserve, a completely other; with the two sharing very little space in the middle. A Western need to “know” and compartmentalize different identities is linked to feelings of anxiety surrounding what is perceived as “White,” “Indian,” “Straight,” and other normative categories of being.
Kent retells the story of how his grandmother was accused of squatting on the land she had homesteaded on for decades, the land which she raised her children and grandchildren on. Due to the fact that she had been classified and compartmentalized as a “treaty Indian” the government required her to move, continuing a history of forced dispossession common in Canada.
| The Examination |
Kent Monkman identifies as a two-spirited gay man Artist, but also has an alter ego named Miss Chief Eagle Testikle. He seeks to reinsert this sexual discourse, which has been lost in colonial society, into the traditional landscapes of his paintings. He explains in his interview that many white painters, including American painter George Catlin (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Catlin), wrote in their journals that they observed non-heteronormative behaviour; however chose not to paint them as it didn’t ‘fit’. Catlin wrote about encountering ‘Native American dandies’ (non-heterosexuals), however painted some of the most famous and stereotypical Indigenous American portraits. Below are two paintings by Kent which help to explain this situation.
| Canyon with Clouds |
| Treason of Images |
Monkman seeks to create a counter narrative of sexuality and history which is breaking the bounds of art and performance. To view his work, please click here http://kentmonkman.com/main.php
Reclamation of identity is an ongoing process and struggle. Art,has been a way in which native identity has been reclaimed and continued to be reclaimed.
No comments:
Post a Comment