Friday, February 22, 2013

Sisters in Spirit: Thoughts on this week's events


This week in class we learned about the Native Women’s Association of Canada (NWAC) Sisters in Spirit (SIS) campaign. Professor Jafri made a comment about the federal government transferring funding for this program from the NWAC to federal police authorities, and this sparked my interest and I decided to look more into this issue.

The SIS campaign ran from 2005-2010.  It was a research, education, and policy initiative driven and led by Aboriginal women, with a goal to conduct research and raise awareness of the violence against Aboriginal women and girls in Canada. It was successful in gathering statistical information on violence against Aboriginal women and created a sophisticated database with over 200 variables. The research of the SIS campaign proved there was at least 582 missing and murdered Aboriginal women and girls in Canada. SIS is recognized and respected by international human rights organizations, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch. 

The federal government provided $5 million between 2005 and 2011 towards the four main goals of SIS:


1.     establish a national toll-free line to report missing Aboriginal women;

2.    awareness and educate the public to better understand the case to the public and to publicize the impact, causes and consequences of violence against Aboriginal women;
3.    undertake a policy analysis of the relevant legal framework at national and international affects or does not the violence perpetrated against Aboriginal women in Canada;
4.    provide comprehensive recommendations that could change from research to policy analysis.

In 2010, NWAC was once again considered for funding by the federal government. While they received funds to run other initiatives of the organization, the SIS program was excluded from government funding and the development of public policy. As can be seen in this press release, NWAC was excluded from government action addressing violence against aboriginal women, and authority on the matter was transferred to the RCMP. The press release states, “We cannot wait until 2013 for the RCMP to have their database up and running – this issue is too important.”

It’s 2013.

This past Saturday, host of the CBC Radio show The House, Evan Soloman contacted the RCMP to confirm that there are 580 cases of aboriginal women missing or killed. Keep in mind, he is confirming a number provided three years prior. This only includes cases up until 2010. The radio show can be listened to here. The RCMP said they were not aware of about 500 of the missing or killed women. 



500 of 582 missing or aboriginal women the RCMP were not “aware” of.  Does the SIS campaign not count of making them “aware” of these women?

There is a complicating factor here: The RCMP claims that SIS only shared the names of 118 victims with them. From this list, they could only confirm 64, using the current police database.

And of course, the RCMP was clear to mention that they investigate all cases of missing and killed people, regardless of sex, ethnicity, background, or lifestyle, and have “special programs” which investigate aboriginal women.

NWAC stated in their 2010 press release that they wanted to establish a transparent partnership with the government, where NWAC is consulted. This would result in the creation of accurate information, so they can begin to address the root cause of violence. This sounds like a good start, but clearly this isn’t happening. There is a power struggle between the two groups, and they don’t even seem to be sharing information, not to mention collaborating or consulting.

I am startled by the claim that the NWAC only shared the names of 118 women. Why? On Sunday, NWAC released a press release responding to the RCMP’s comments to the CBC questioning the 582 women.  It does not address the allegation of only sharing 118 names. I can only hope that they address this soon.

But the onus is not just on NWAC. It is unacceptable that the RCMP’s  “special programs,” “investigations,” and “database” is just cross-listing SIS information with their own previous information, and then dismissing any cases not on the previous RCMP database. This discredits the work of the NWAC, and does not recognize their expertise and knowledge.  It assumes the work of the RCMP to be superior and solely legitimate.  The reason SIS came to be was because institutional justice systems were not accurately representing or taking action on the issue of violence against aboriginal women. Further research was desperately needed. And now that research (which took a lot of money, time, and passion) is being dismissed.  Sadly, even that research is limited. As stated in NWAC’s Sunday press release,

    “NWAC acknowledges that the number often cited by the research and scope of the Sisters In Spirit project is limited… NWAC continues to receive requests from families and communities searching for a loved one or missing community members. There are times when the name search turns up a blank, this tells us that the NWAC Database is not up to date and has not captured all incidents. These are indicators that the number is much higher and we have NOT recorded all cases of missing or murdered Aboriginal women and girls… Grassroots groups that have also been collecting this data often state that the NWAC researched numbers are not correct, and that there continues to be an ongoing issue in the matter of missing and murdered Aboriginal women and girls that no one is officially keeping track of, which is very disconcerting to us.”

I think it is shameful that the number is the subject of debate. We would never debate how many middle-upper class white women are missing or killed right now because each case is taken seriously, fully investigated, and that number is known. The fact that we’re arguing about the number illustrates that aboriginal peoples are a demographic on the fringe of society, on the fringe of the rights that settler Canadians receive. If Aboriginal women continue to be a target for violence, for racism or any other reason, then the question should not be the number of victims, (that should be certain) but what programs can be implemented to protect women and reverse the system which allows it to persist! The RCMP has the resources and the power to make these changes, and NWAC has the expertise, cultural understanding, and knowledge to make these changes. They could do so much working together.

Then why are the two bodies at such a power struggle?

NWAC’s 2010 press release discussed collaboration and partnership with the federal government, but Sunday’s press release had a very different vibe, stating:


            “It appears now that the RCMP has chosen aggressive bullying tactics to re-direct public attention away from its own internal issues. This is another justification for NWAC’s call for a long-overdue national public inquiry that will, once and for all, look at the issue of missing and murdered Aboriginal women girls including the attitude of the police forces that should be there to protect them and not discredit the organizations that are trying to shed light on this matter,” said President Audette.”

It seems to me that the first step to solving this issue is for the two groups to respect each other for what they can provide, and recognize their own limitations.  As I said before, The RCMP has the resources and the power and NWAC has the expertise, cultural understanding, and knowledge.

But then….why isn’t this being done? If the federal government were to allow this to happen, it would uncover what the NWAC has been trying to say for years. It would uncover that Canada continues to brutally oppress a group of people based on “sex, ethnicity, background, or lifestyle.” It would prove that Canada is a colonial nation. The liberal Canadian image of peace and multiculturalism is depended on. It shows Canada as a nation that frowns upon apartheid and slavery. Canada provide avenues of prosperity for all of their people! In order to keep this image, the federal government must hide the truth, which is that their own policing and justice system has no freaking clue where 518 aboriginal women, probably more, before 2010 are… and they have no intention on looking.

Helpful links:

No comments:

Post a Comment