Friday, March 1, 2013

Intervention in Canadian Law and Policy: Politicial Engagement through Social Activism

The readings assigned in this weeks class address the importance of a marriage of Aboriginal women’s theory, organizing and activism in effecting positive formal and substantive changes in law and politics for the express benefit of Aboriginal women, and Aboriginal communities at large. 

In Balancing Strategies: Aboriginal Women and Constitutional Rights in Canada, Joyce Green states that Canada’s current electoral system discourages disenfranchised and marginalized bodies and groups from pursuing democratic engagement through traditional political party involvement. But rather, she claims that activists and activist groups prefer to engage with the state through participation in social movements, claiming that theses avenues have been powerful actors in effecting formal changes in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms as well as within the Canadian Constitution. The formal changes in Canadian law and policy that have been advanced by Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s activist groups and organizations are specifically oriented towards Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s issues, for example: land rights, political autonomy and sovereignty, and respect for culture and tradition. However, Green addresses the unfortunate reality that change in law and policy rarely affects the tangible and practical realties of the everyday lived experience of disenfranchised and marginalized groups.

Green’s idea that disenfranchised and marginalized groups can, and should, participate in social activist movements and organizations in order to effectively affect changes within the Canadian political and legal systems is echoed in Smith’s article, Against the Law: Indigenous Feminism and the Nation-State. Smith argues that many non-white/ Aboriginal peoples consider their bodies and agendas to be outside or othered from mainstream feminist projects. She states that feelings of isolation and alienation from mainstream feminist projects discourage Aboriginal women from participating in, contributing to and drawing on valid and useful theoretical frameworks. As such, Smith promotes a Native feminist approach that interrogates the everyday practical and material conditions that Native women experience as subjects situated within patriarchal and colonial nation-states. Here too, as in Green’s article, Smith stresses the importance of this native feminist approach to theory and practice (activism and organizing) in decolonizing the American nation state in order to expose the fallacy of its foundation that is so effectively occluded. Again, Smith calls for an approach to Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s theory and activism that works against oppressive law and policy that promote, support and condone state-sponsored racism, domination and violence.

After reading the Green and Smith article I started to consider the ways in which colonial nation-states are able to effectively obscure the oppressive and violent histories and foundations that inform and (re)produce their current incarnations. In particular, I began thinking about injustice and discrimination that pervades Canadian laws and policies and the ways in which Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s organizations and activists work to expose inequality and negotiate positive changes that empower Aboriginal peoples, specifically Aboriginal women. 


It is clear that formal guarantees of equality in Canada do not translate to just and equal practical manifestations of the everyday lived experience of Aboriginal and diverse non-white identities.  Certainly, myriad factors and social intersections contribute to experiences of (dis)empowerment under these systems and Canadians experience the implications of Canadian law and policy in very different, and ultimately unequal, ways. However, formal guarantees of equality and justice in Canadian law and policy obscures the everyday reality that injustice and inequality pervades these systems. Because injustice and inequality are obscured by the disconnect between the formal and the substantive, those privileged by the system do not recognize the gap between the legal, policies and the theoretical on one hand and the practical, tangible and lived experience on the other. Uncritical consumption of ideology and discourse, that posits Canada’s political and legal systems as unquestioningly egalitarian, promotes dangerous ahistorical understandings of colonialism as a project of the past. These understandings minimize, undermine and create resistance by the mainstream to the organizing and activism of Aboriginal and Aboriginal women’s groups in the struggle for self-determination and equality in practice and in theory. 


A relevant example of Aboriginal organizing and activism in terms of addressing injustice and inequality in the disconnect between Canadian law and policy on one hand and implementation on the other is the protest movement Idle no More. Idle no More pursues activism in response to unfair law and policy of the Canadian federal government through various political actions and interventions. Idle no more is invested in addressing violations of the Treaties that degrade their land rights, environmental protections and sovereignty, specifically violations imposed by Bill C-45. I chose to consider Idle no More because the various road and rail blockades that were implemented across Canada by the group in the late months of 2012 and early 2013 generated a lot of mainstream interest and resistance in the Queen’s community (particularly regarding the rail blockades on the route between Kingston and Toronto). 

 

I was appalled at the response to the protests that I heard from many of my peers who felt that they had been inconvenienced by the blockades. Many of the complaints I heard were in response to cancelled or delayed trains, complicating their trips back home. I remember listening to some of my peers claiming that equality in Canada had been reached, calling the protests greedy, uncalled for inconveniences. I think that these  are echoed in the comment sections of the below Globe and Mail articles (which detail the protests and provide a brief overviews of the concerns and goals of Idle no More). 

·    
-->


I remember being simultaneously angry and confused at my peer’s resistance to the Idle no More protests on grounds that equality in Canada had been achieved. While I am convinced that many of my peers didn’t really care about equality and justice for Aboriginal peoples, and were really primarily concerned with their trips home, I also think that there is a lack of (and a resistance to) understanding the reality of the implications and enforcement of Canadian law and policy on aboriginal bodies. I think that this weeks material helped me to understand that the disconnect between theory and practice in law and policy affects public perception of the ways in which marginalized groups in Canada experience inequality and discrimination. 


The disconnect between formal guarantees and practical implications necessitates Aboriginal activism and organization to engage Canadian legal and political systems in order to create an effective politics of resistance and secure equality. It is clear that the Canadian nation state has effectively obscured the violent and racist roots of its foundation that re(produce) the continuing marginalization and disenfranchisement of Aboriginal bodies. In achieving illusions of multiculturalism, acceptance and equality, through formal guarantees and provisions, the Canadian nation state and its privileged subjects are able to overlook and disregard the domination and disenfranchisement of its marginalized subjects, and justify backlash, criticism and resistance to Aboriginal activism, protest and political agendas.

No comments:

Post a Comment