Friday, March 15, 2013

The "Imaginary Indian"


I tend to imagine things- a lot. I find myself reconstructing my life in my head, rearranging the things that make up who I am, what I do, where I live.

I imagine myself because there, I am the master of my own universe- and it feels damn good.

When things are imagined we can wish them away, make them fit into our narrow conceptions of reality, recreate them in relation to our own senses of self.

These are the things I have been thinking about this week while engaging with the course readings surrounding “the imaginary Indian”. Since the European ‘master narrative’ has come onto the scene, Indigenous people have been recreated as fictitious characters which fit into a fictions history.

I find it sort of funny; I live with two history majors who won’t even watch the news because, to them, it hasn’t really happened yet. Therefore it isn’t history, it isn’t in the past and able to observe, debate, quantify.
 
This is the aspect which struck me the most, when I was reading Marcia Crosby’s article “Constructing the Imaginary Indian”. For a long time, due to the colonial nature of history, we ‘studied’ and observed Indigenous people as though they no longer existed. They are history because they have no future, due to discourses of binary polarization where the future is modern, progressive, civilized and this is an incompatible reality from living an ‘Indigenous life’. People were seen as indigenous subjects, who were to be saved through colonization and civilization.

But Indigenous people exist. One of my best friends identifies as Cree, and she goes to pow-wows, goes to school, paints in a style which reminds her of her heritage, and has a status card. She lives a life in the modern world, as a modern person; not an archaic subject.

(Let me bring in Foucault for a second...)

Foucault talks about biopolitics. It’s not that sensitive topics like sex cannot be discussed at all, but only certain people, in certain contexts have the power to do so. It has been demonstrated that the colonial narrative is acted on Indigenous people, in such a way, that they became unable to legitimately discuss themselves as people. They become objects of the colonial gaze and things frozen in a specific time and place.

Crosby discusses the feeling of not being able to embrace the notion of the ‘authentic’ Indian which she saw reproduced by the Western science of anthropology. As she was sitting in class being impressed by this huge amount of knowledge her professor had on Indigenous subject matter, he still looked to her for verification.
She found herself embarrassed by her lack of knowledge but, for the first time, presented with a positive stereotype of what a `real’ Indian should be like. Despite all his knowledge, the professor was still unknowingly constructing Crosby, in a way which she did not self-identify nor did she feel like she had ownership over.

I feel as though as racially, socially, economically privileged people; we are constantly guilty of this; where we construct the identities of those who do not have as much power.

This can be due to the education system, an unfortunate effect of having two histories running parallel to one another, where neither of them have been intertwined. Crosby speaks to the paradox where people are criticized for only teaching/speaking about Eurocentric history; but at the same time should not speak to cultures and histories where they have to make assumptions. The solution to this is bringing in members of these communities in order to discuss their work, first hand, but this is somewhat unrealistic in certain contexts.

The Crosby text discusses counter narratives which need to take into account the juxtaposition of this imaginedness, while attempting to reclaim narratives. George Bowering’s text Burning Water is a historical parody of George Vancouver’s ‘discovery’ of the northwest coast. He presents the subject matter as drunken, dirty, promiscuous Indian women. For those who know that this description is a parody, they understand that this is a critique of the ‘master narrative’ and does not describe reality. In reality, Crosby notes that Bowering does not consider that there is very little primary information about Indigenous people in the education system. So little, in fact, that readers would have a hard time determining that this text is parody and perhaps could interpret these descriptions as reality.

A similar situation occurred at the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) in the late 1990’s when they put on the show “Into the Heart of Africa”. For the first time African artifacts were put on display for the public, but there was intense backlash from the Afro-Canadian community. Most of the artifacts had been collected during colonial times, or by missionaries and were accompanied by captions similar to what Bowering did in his text. Pictures of tribal warriors were accompanied by phrases like “uncivilized” or “barbaric culture”, all in quotation marks. These quotation marks were supposed to indicate to the observer that these assumptions were wrong, and that it was not the opinion of the exhibit, but rather the opinion of a group of people involved in this history, who ‘collected’ this history. The Afro-Canadian community had grievances that an uneducated audience would not understand that these phrases were supposed to be satirical, and would take them at face value.

This exhibit therefore was geared to a certain educated audience, making this exhibit inaccessible for those who were not privy to information on colonialism or missionaries; therefore cutting off all opportunity for a wider audience to enjoy it. Yes, these artifacts had to be observed in a certain historical context, however I question the validity of placing them in the colonial context, disregarding whether or not these artefacts were collected during this time.

More of a gap must be bridged between mainstream Eurocentric education, and those who wish to offer a counter-narrative. I believe that it will be necessary to completely refigure what education means, how it is taught and how information is collected- in order to properly close this gap.

Last year in DEVS 300, one of our TAs Shauna Shiels, got up to speak about her research concerning reclaiming Indigenous methodologies. How objects and artifacts, such as beadwork and clothing that typically would be put in a museum because they are things to be observed. In reality these ‘artifacts’ actually tell stories and can be critical and self-reflexive. Objects that the West defined as ‘pretty things’, actually have deep cultural and historical meaning and the mediums in which they are made are significant too; understanding that there are different ways to disseminate knowledge and history- beyond writing it down.
That the legitimacy of information does not necessarily involve a pen, paper, and an ‘expert’ in the traditional western education sense!

But for now they do. For now, the realness of my education is defined by those things. The legitimacy of a huge part of who I am (a student) rest on how well I reconcile with this notion of education- and I can only hope that this will change.


No comments:

Post a Comment